Le sue specifiche (riserva di carica, frequenza) non sono ancora state rivelate. orologi replica Come al solito con JLC, la decorazione è molto piacevole: viti azzurrate, angoli smussati, parti in acciaio lucidate a specchio, strisce di Ginevra irradianti.

Compared with the previous generation 240 movement, replica watches uk the size of the 260 Pearl Tuo movement has increased significantly, and the movement board has been redesigned.

replica orologi italia

Si buscas una replica relojes Rolex. replicarelojes.to la mejor web del 2022

Select Page

Looking for:

A Day of Diving in the Gili Islands: What to Expect – Manta Dive Center and Resort Gili Air.

Click here to Download


Within populations Ward-Paige et al. Over the past decade, research advances on the applied to other taxa and provide suggestions about how these biology and ecology of mobulid rays have supported a number could be adapted for use in future mobulid research.

Mobulid of international, national, and local management actions focused rays remain a poorly studied group, and therefore our list of on halting or reversing population declines Croll et al. However, we hope that The majority of previous research efforts have focused on this identification of high priority knowledge gaps will stimulate manta rays previously genus Manta but now included in genus and focus future mobulid research. Mobula; White et al. Mobula alfredi is the best studied member of the 1.

Without it, human impacts These attributes facilitate field research activities and on evolutionary and ecologically distinct groups cannot be allow for long-term monitoring of populations that is critical accurately evaluated. Key advances in this field include an for studying the ecology, life history, and population dynamics initial revisionary study of the genus Mobula Notarbartolo di of the species e. In contrast, the species in Sciara, , the resurrection of M.

Recent public and conservation species where there were previously 11 White et al. Despite progress in mobulid research over the past decade, 1. Clarifying Existing Taxonomy major knowledge gaps still exist.

Considerable action has been There is an urgent requirement to resolve species boundaries taken to curb targeted fisheries for these species, but bycatch further in the genus Mobula to underpin conservation and remains a persistent threat Croll et al. Fisheries impacts management. White et al. However, M. Previous work supports the Frontiers in Marine Science www. Superscript numbers refer to sections in the paper with detailed descriptions and recommendations for future research addressing each topic and using each method.

Figure design by Madeline Wukusick www. It is group Poortvliet et al. The challenge, therefore, will be important to note that in all cases of synonymy in White distinguishing distinct species where hybridization and historical et al. However, a more detailed including replicates within localities, should be collected and population level study previously revealed them to be distinct analyzed to minimize the introduction of ascertainment bias, species that had experienced introgression, obscuring genetic and encompass intra-specific variation.

In addition, given separation Kashiwagi et al. In the case of M. Investigation variation. Clarifying the taxonomy of the M. We therefore strongly M. Given the scarcity of modern sightings and of morphological considerations. Such studies should also make samples of M. There is also a need to susceptibility of mobulid rays to Illegal, Unreported and consider interactions between species given current evidence Unregulated IUU fishing. Future research should include a Frontiers in Marine Science www.

Research Priorities for Mobulid Rays comprehensive survey of the West African coastline to collect et al. Wherever possible, life-history specimens and investigate diversity within the region. For parameter estimates should be obtained and applied to the purposes of this paper, we identify existing research and management at the population level, as biological characteristics knowledge gaps for M. Regional differences may be especially cf.

Available estimates of mobulid extinction risk suggest that mobulid ray populations 1. Cryptic Diversity are unlikely to withstand current levels of fishing mortality, even In addition to the currently recognized M. Therefore, accurate estimates of life history parameters been hypothesized for almost a decade Marshall et al.

Conclusive fisheries management scenarios. Age and Growth Hinojosa-Alvarez et al. However, a formal description In elasmobranchs, growth is usually modeled by estimating the of M. Rediscovery of such as fin spines Cailliet et al. The vertebral centra cryptic diversity within manta rays in the early Twenty-first of devil rays tend to be poorly calcified, which has hindered Century was the result of detailed morphological observation of the use of this technique so far.

Currently, only one data set many individuals of several populations combined with genetic has provided size-at-age estimates to model growth rates using analyses of multiple genes Marshall et al. The lack of equivalent studies for the remaining M. Further efforts should assess this method in within the group cannot be ruled out, and thus we recommend other species and locations, since the extent of calcification additional detailed taxonomic studies for mobulid rays generally.

Researchers should strive to obtain samples from a Further, population level sampling enables opportunities for broad size-range and estimate growth parameters using a multi- studies to define Evolutionarily Significant Units ESUs for model approach i. To support future morphometric Logistic models Smart et al.

In data-poor situations and meristic-based studies, we strongly encourage research or when a size-class is poorly represented, back-calculation, or groups and collections to improve reference material at the Bayesian methods may allow for adequate estimates Cailliet population level to effectively catalog mobulid diversity.

These et al. An important assumption is should include tissue samples for molecular analysis; whole that each pair of opaque and translucent bands is deposited specimens where possible; partial specimens of species- and annually Cailliet et al. Validating this assumption in region-specific characters such as gill plates, spiral valves, and mobulid rays could be attempted by injection of a fluorochrome tooth-bands; and high-quality images with a scale bar of the label e.

Alternatively, radiocarbon 14 C dating of archival devil ray hard parts could provide Life-history information is needed to estimate extinction risk, a method of age validation by tracing this dated chemical maximum population growth rates in data-poor species, and marker released in high concentrations during atomic bomb for performing stock assessments Musick, ; Pardo et al.

Additionally, a,b. Many chondrichthyans have highly conservative life- researchers could evaluate the feasibility of using cesium isotopes history characteristics, and mobulid rays have some of the released during the Fukushima nuclear accident to assist with most conservative traits, making them vulnerable to overfishing age validation for mobulids in the western Pacific Neville et al.

These slow- Until validation is achieved, researchers can test band- growing rays have very low rates of reproduction and long pair deposition consistency across years as a means of verification maturation times Notarbartolo di Sciara, ; Marshall and Cailliet et al. Bennett, ; Dulvy et al. Key life history parameters such as age at maturity, fished specimens and therefore is not appropriate in many wild growth rate, lifespan, mortality both natural and fisheries- mobulid ray populations. Direct estimates of growth rate can be induced and fecundity are lacking for most mobulid species obtained in-situ from morphometric measurements of resighted Table 1.

Estimating these parameters is crucial for assessing individuals over known time increments, based on visual the vulnerability and demography of exploited populations size estimates Kitchen-Wheeler et al. Notarbartolo di Notarbartolo di embryo Randall, embryos, Broadhurst and embryos, Cadenat, and Carvalho, et al. Laglbauer unpublished; ; West Coast , Western Philippines.

Sciara and Serena, California. Central Atlantic. Rambahiniarison and Last, ; Kashiwagi, ; 1, et al. Rambahiniarison et al. Stevens, ; Maldives. Frontiers in Marine Science www. Sciara, ; ; Indonesia. Gulf of California. Stevens, ; unpublished data; Rambahiniarison et al. Sri Lanka, India, ; Philippines. Kashiwagi, ; Japan. Notarbartolo di ; Alabama. Notarbartolo di Sciara et al.

India, Malaysia. Stevens, See section 2. Matrix used to fit growth curves e. Therefore, further efforts should among mobulid rays Heppell et al. As key life history aim to obtain accurate size estimates over longer time frames to data become available, future research on mobulids should estimate growth rates. It will also be important to obtain accurate use sensitivity, elasticity, and perturbation analyses to identify estimates of size-at-birth from neonates or late-term embryos life stages with significant contributions to overall population across populations since these are necessary to fit two-parametric viability in order to direct management actions Heppell, ; growth models, which are preferable to three-parametric models Frisk et al.

Additionally, researchers could assess the that sometimes provide unrealistic estimates of size at birth in impact of specific management approaches by quantitatively elasmobranchs Smart et al. Mortality ; Smart et al. Further, in cases where time-series of Mortality is an essential parameter to understand population abundance or relative abundance are not available which is the dynamics, and it is important for demographic models and case for many mobulid populations , these life history parameters stock assessments to separate natural mortality from fishing can be used to calculate the maximum growth rate of a population mortality.

There are a number of methods researchers can Pardo et al. This can be compared with total mortality use to estimate mortality in mobulid rays depending on both to determine population trajectories and extinction risk Pardo data availability and type. In data-rich wild populations, mark- et al. In fisheries scenarios, catch curve analysis of landed specimens allows for The reproductive biology of mobulid rays is known mostly direct estimates of total mortality natural plus fishing mortality from the reef manta ray M.

Courtship and copulation e. Many indirect in reef manta rays are common around cleaning stations and methods exist to estimate mortality based on other life history reef habitats Marshall and Bennett, ; Deakos et al. The most relevant Deakos, ; Stevens, ; Stevens et al. Observations approaches to mobulid research likely include estimation of of courtship and mating remain rare in other mobulid species natural mortality from maximum age e. Uchida et al. All mobulids are thought to 2.

Population Viability give birth to a single large pup, with rare observations of twins The life history information highlighted in this section is Marshall et al.

Parturition is often important for developing management strategies that prioritize followed immediately by copulation in captive and wild M. Research Priorities for Mobulid Rays Uchida et al.

Little is known about parturition in mobulid is likely to be found in other mobulid species, as well Stevens, rays. To date, no natural wild birth for any mobulid species ; Duffy and Scott, In wild populations of M. Advanced technology may be required to interbirth intervals of 2—7 years have been reported, presumably determine if specific pupping grounds exist, or if females give dependent on environmental conditions and food availability birth in any area with suitable conditions.

Researchers could Marshall and Bennett, ; Deakos, ; Kashiwagi, ; use satellite and acoustic tags to evaluate the movements and Stevens, The fecundities of mobulids other than M. Additionally, animal-borne video demographic analyses have assumed that mobulids share similar camera systems e. Size segregation appears to be common across mobulid allow for more detailed examinations of environments being species, with juveniles absent from most field studies or present used.

Deakos, G. Stevens observed within the general population Marshall and Bennett, unpublished and occasionally in offshore habitats R. Rubin In terms of movements, habitat use and general life history unpublished segregated from adult populations. Additionally, data, the juvenile life stage of all mobulid species remains poorly juvenile M. To date two locations have been identified Maturity assessments of mobulids are based primarily on external that meet established criteria for elasmobranch nursery habitats morphological cues, such as changes in clasper morphology in Heupel et al.

However, physiological sexual maturity may locations are currently undergoing similar assessments. Future not coincide with the external signs of sexual maturation. Ultrasonography has also been widely adopted to define gonadal Given the apparent affinity for protected coastal and maturity in a variety of fish species Bryan et al. Future research addressing mobulid sites. The identification of mating and pupping grounds may reproduction and fecundity could consider applying these also aid in the identification of juvenile habitats and nursery methods, particularly in species where individual identification grounds.

For example, large annual aggregations of M. If used in the Gulf of California, Mexico are presumed to be mating on a sufficiently large scale, these approaches could help estimate aggregations. Juvenile and potential young-of-year individuals the proportion of females within a population contributing have been observed along the coast adjacent to these aggregations to annual recruitment and, for data collected over extended Notarbartolo di Sciara, G.

Stewart, pers. If In combination with photogrammetry, ultrasonography and mating pupping, and nursery habitats are identified, these endocrinology would enable more reliable estimates of age and critical habitats should be protected to prevent changes in size at maturity.

Mating, Pupping, and Nursery Areas areas. In several mobulid species, reproductive activity peaks seasonally and may occur more often at social aggregation sites such a seamounts or cleaning stations Yano et al. However, significant knowledge gaps remain in our understanding of With increasing concern for the general status of global mobulid courtship and mating behavior. Long-term monitoring mobulid populations, estimates of abundance, and breeding of areas where opportunistic courtship activity has been stock along with monitoring of long-term population trends documented previously may reveal more seasonal mating are crucial measures required to develop effective management grounds for certain species, and targeted surveillance of social and conservation strategies.

Current population information for aggregation sites would be a natural starting place to undertake manta rays is predominantly gathered through diver counts and Frontiers in Marine Science www. Mating, pupping and nursery grounds are not well defined for mobulids. See section 3. The at predictable aggregation sites. Researchers should carefully consider ; Marshall and Pierce, ; Couturier et al. However, the analytical methods they plan to employ and the key photo-ID is limited to species with individually unique markings parameters they wish to recover, and plan their data collection e.

Therefore, there is a need to investigate is recapture rate: the probability of observing an individual additional methods to assess population trends, especially for animal on subsequent events.

Patchy data often result in devil rays. Photo Identification determination of trends. The use of auxiliary data within mark- Of all mobulid species, M.

For example, the incorporation of acoustic ; Kitchen-Wheeler et al. The large variation in body pigmentation estimation for this species Dudgeon et al.

Several patterns, presumed to be unique to each individual from birth, mobulid research programs already include tagging studies facilitates the cataloging of individuals and the creation of photo- see Movements section and future research programs could ID databases Kumli and Rubin, ; Kitchen-Wheeler et al.

The popularity of in-water data across multiple studies. Rigorous sampling designs can interactions with mobulids has also resulted in a high incidence also increase the utility of citizen science data. For example, of citizen science contributions to regional photo-ID databases focusing citizen science efforts during particular time periods from recreational divers Kumli and Rubin, ; Couturier can increase data input into analysis frameworks, as well as et al.

In addition to benefiting researchers by expanding data sightings Mengersen et al. Ongoing surveys of well- collection spatially and temporally without additional cost or studied populations should be continued to enable long-term resource use, citizen science promotes public awareness, and trends to be assessed.

Oceanic manta rays M. Both species have chevron a,c and black b morphs. See section 4. Relative Abundance, Data Poor such as catch curve analysis Pardo et al. Where robust estimates of through individual identification photo-ID, tag, and release is current population sizes are available e. Other approaches therefore need Dulvy et al.

In populations of mobulids that may exhibit varying management schemes, environmental conditions, and high site affinity and recapture rates, researchers could evaluate climate change scenarios. Genetic Approaches to Estimating for abundance estimation. Indirect or relative estimates of Abundance abundance can be generated through: a count surveys SPUE: New developments in genomic approaches show promise for sighting per unit effort of live animals e.

DNA can b observer data of capture rates CPUE: catch per unit effort be extracted from small amounts of tissue collected from live or BPUE: bycatch per unit effort , or c landed animals at fish or dead animals as well as preserved components such as markets CPUE. As life history parameters and population gill plates. High throughput sequencing enables thousands of estimates become available for mobulids, researchers should genetic markers to be sequenced most commonly focusing on use traditional stock assessment methods to evaluate the status single nucleotide polymorphisms—SNPs , which can then be and trends of populations Methot and Wetzel, However, used in multiple population genetic analyses.

One approach this will most likely only be possible in fisheries that have high is estimating genetic effective population size Ne , which observer coverage or bycatch reporting e. In as a metric of population viability. Strong concordance has more common data-poor scenarios, researchers could take been demonstrated between ecological and genetic estimates advantage of existing length- and age-based assessment methods of abundance for some elasmobranch species Portnoy et al.

The slow population growth rates of mobulid populations for mobulids also demonstrating concordance for M. Investigations are ongoing for fisheries Dulvy et al. Consequently, M. Armstrong unpublished and future research should focus on assessing bycatch risks and Mozambique S. Venables unpublished. The advantage of Ne mitigation efforts as well as the impacts of existing fisheries on is that only a single population sample is required to generate mobulid populations.

Theoretically, changes in Ne with temporal sampling can demonstrate population trends e. Post-release Mortality et al. However, given that demography, ecology, and While fisheries regulations have sought to prevent the retention reproductive mode can all influence Ne estimates Wang, , and landing of mobulid rays, the vast majority of mobulid future research is needed to investigate the sensitivity of Ne to captures are a result of unintentional bycatch Croll et al.

Physical and biological traits of rays i. Another emerging molecular skeleton to protect internal organs, relatively high metabolic approach to estimating population size is close-kin mark- rates make them particularly vulnerable to handling while recapture CKMR; Bravington et al. Genomic data they are out of water Poisson et al. In the past, are used to identify kin pairs including parent-offspring, full onboard handling practices have resulted in high levels of siblings and half-siblings.

Marking occurs during reproduction post-release mortality Hall and Roman, ; Poisson et al. CKMR has been applied to mitigation plan for mobulids have defined suitable technical natural populations of bluefin tuna Bravington et al.

Recent resolutions prohibiting only provides information about adults and requires sampling harmful handling practices like gaffing and punching holes in a substantial proportion of the population to identify kinship the bodies of rays were approved by the IATTC, and have begun pairs and generate abundance estimates Bravington et al.

With few published examples for mortality. Evaluating survival rates of mobulids released alive CKMR, sampling guidelines are not yet available, however several in non-target fisheries will help guide management decisions, elasmobranch studies are underway Ovenden et al.

Initial studies of M. Researchers should evaluate the post- release mortality of mobulids captured incidentally in a variety The greatest contributors to direct mortality of mobulid rays of gear types, as fishing gear such as gill nets with long soak across their range are targeted and bycatch fisheries Croll et al. At least 13 fisheries in 12 countries specifically target than long lines or purse seines. Additionally, future studies mobulids, and at least 30 fisheries in 23 countries capture should evaluate the impact of handling and release methods and mobulids as bycatch Hall and Roman, ; Croll et al.

Post-release mortality can be evaluated et al. India, and Mozambique Couturier et al. The attraction In coastal fisheries where released mobulids are more likely to of mobulids to productive tropical and subtropical habitats remain in range of acoustic receivers, researchers could also where target species such as tunas aggregate, along with their consider the use of acoustic tags to evaluate survivorship rates distribution in the epipelagic zone, make them vulnerable to Skomal, Accelerometer tags may also be useful in the fisheries capture Croll et al.

Mobulids are targeted or quantification of post-release behavior and mortality and the caught as bycatch in virtually every fishing gear type, including impacts of handling methods in cases where instrument recovery small-scale fisheries characterized by the use of driftnets, gillnets, is feasible Whitney et al. As relationships between harpoons, gaffs, traps, trawls, and longlines; and large-scale directly observable covariates e. The level of bycatch depends greatly on the fishing commercial fisheries should strive to collect fishery-wide data on method used, with the highest bycatch rates reported from these covariates, which will allow managers to estimate the total gillnets and purse seiners Croll et al.

Mobulid rays are captured incidentally in virtually all fishing gear types, and are also targeted for their meat and gill plates in some countries. See section 5.

Species Distributions and Fishery Data current bycatch estimates. Many of these vessels operate Standardization in nearshore productive waters where mobulids aggregate, Identifying areas of overlap between mobulid hotspots and and are likely to represent substantial unreported mobulid fisheries could help reduce mobulid bycatch rates.

Concurrent bycatch. Further research is necessary to describe the nature satellite tracking of focal species and vessel monitoring systems and quantity of this bycatch e.

Onboard fisheries observers provide far more data-rich scenarios 5. Bycatch Prevention and Mitigation in which to assess bycatch risk, especially in commercial fisheries Bycatch mitigation methods have not been adequately explored with high observer coverage such as the IATTC tuna purse for mobulids, and proposals for preventing interactions between seine fleet Hall and Roman, ; Croll et al.

These fishing gear and mobulids through technological innovations observer records allow for detailed species distribution models or gear modifications are needed.

Strong associations with the that can reveal relationships between species abundance and thermocline in M. Future studies should bycatch rates of this species, and incorporating water column identify the regions with both the highest overall mobulid dynamics into species distribution models could help identify bycatch rates, and the highest mobulid bycatch to target catch important bycatch hotspots Brodie et al.

However, ratios. This information will allow managers to develop spatio- the feasibility of limiting gear depth in commercial fisheries temporal and ideally dynamic management approaches with is questionable, and therefore alternate proposals should be the greatest ecological and conservation value for mobulids developed and tested for mobulids more generally.

Bycatch and the lowest economic loss from reduced catches of target mitigation has been developed for many non-target marine species. However, to take full advantage of fisheries observer species such as seabirds in long-line fisheries e. Researchers Crowder et al. For elasmobranchs more generally, there could work with regional fisheries management organizations have been various trials, such as the apparently unsuccessful RFMOs to develop a comprehensive, standardized data use of rare-earth metals to deter sharks from baited hooks collection manual for mobulids that ensures all relevant variables, Jordan et al.

Some studies suggest among regions and fisheries. Additionally, RFMOs should that the use of light-emitting diodes in or near the ultraviolet be encouraged to implement detailed mobulid identification range may reduce bycatch of elasmobranchs in gill net fisheries training courses, and researchers could follow up with molecular Jordan et al.

Unfortunately, these approaches will not cover pers. Research Priorities for Mobulid Rays indicate that populations are spatially structured Stewart et al.

Identifying common physical and biological processes a. Consequently, fisheries management of mobulid rays that underlie movements and aggregative behavior across species may be more effective and relevant at the stock level, rather will allow for improved identification and characterization of than simply along political or geographic boundaries Reiss et al. Studies of fine-scale habitat use at aggregation More genetic studies are needed to identify genetically sites have revealed that individuals visit these areas to attend distinct populations of mobulid rays to support regional shallow cleaning stations, engage in courtship behavior, and management strategies.

As traditional gene sequencing methods forage on ephemeral food resources Dewar et al. Peterson et al. Satellite Tagging generate robust estimates of population structure. Given that Technological advances in satellite tagging Musyl et al. Fastloc technology, Wildlife Computers and fishing mortality For example, tissue, or tail samples collected by observers in e. Using these, mobulid overexploited fish species have been shown to have lower genetic rays have been successfully tracked for periods of up to a year, diversity than closely related species that are not overharvested revealing regional philopatric movements and strong affinity to Pinsky and Palumbi, We therefore encourage researchers shelf edge habitats in manta rays Braun et al.

This Francis and Jones, In contrast, towed Argos-linked tags will help prioritize vulnerable populations for conservation and require long tethers to facilitate surface satellite communications, management action.

Studies of general patterns of effective leading to shorter deployments poor tag retention but higher population sizes and descriptions of the demographic histories resolution position estimates whenever the tag surfaces. These of mobulids can establish valuable baseline reference points. More recently, towed tags 6.

This theme has surfacing, for periods of up to 6 months M. Erdmann pers. Fastloc positions require less surface time, allowing for decade, with 17 published studies documenting movements of shorter tethers and longer retention times than Argos-linked individuals using a combination of photographic mark-recapture tags, but do not transmit archived high-resolution GPS positions methods and electronic tracking.

Using acoustic and satellite until the tag detaches from the animal. Recent improvements to telemetry, movements of 1, individual rays of 6 species have geolocation and subsequent state space models are quantifying been investigated in 10 distinct regions throughout their range and reducing the levels of uncertainty associated with light- Figure 6.

However, the majority of this effort has been focused based geolocation Patterson et al. It is likely that with the Together, these studies increasing capacity to make fine-scale observations, movement highlight the large movement capacity of manta and devil rays patterns will indicate significant overlap with anthropogenic and their use of broad geographic ranges including coastal and threats or sensitive areas Braun et al.

Researchers could therefore incorporate et al. High rates of site residency metrics such as the Human Impact Index Halpern et al.

Fine-scale habitat use sites up to km apart Couturier et al. The drivers underlying these large seasonal and Fastloc tags, and researchers could make efforts to improve aggregations, common to both manta and devil rays, remain retention times for these tag types, perhaps by implementing new Frontiers in Marine Science www. The mobulid tagging effort information was sourced from published literature on the topic as well as from other unpublished mobulid tracking studies known to the authors and their collaborators summarized in Table S1.

See section 6. Large scale In addition to contributing important spatial information collaborative efforts will inform the design of management about the conservation needs of these species, such information strategies on national or smaller scales Lea et al. Acoustic Tagging Compared with satellite tags, the affordability and longer 6.

Critical Habitats battery life of acoustic tags enables the collection of larger The ability of researchers to identify and predict areas of critical datasets on mobulid movements, site fidelity and habitat use habitat for mobulid rays will be improved with increasing than studies employing satellite tags.

The increased battery amounts of movement data collected through telemetry studies life of acoustic transmitters up to 10 years will also greatly Hays et al. Density maps e.

However, core area use of mobulid species Croll et al. Historical observations of mobulid presence and over months to years remains a challenge. Future studies aggregation events may provide novel and temporal insight into should consider internal tagging where possible e. Kessel species distributions. Researchers should consider Unmanned et al. Additionally, acoustic tags only Aerial Vehicle UAV technology or aerial surveys to provide provide positions when they are in range of acoustic receiver additional opportunities to collect quantitative and behavioral stations, limiting their utility for wide-ranging mobulids that data of mobulids Hodgson et al.

Researchers could Notarbartolo di Sciara et al. It is highly likely that expand monitoring capacity e. Research Priorities for Mobulid Rays et al. Studies should include oceanographic and biological 7. Together, these data can be used in can help identify where these species are most susceptible to ecosystem niche modeling to identify potential new regions direct or incidental capture in fisheries Rohner et al.

The Stewart et al. Increased use of Argos-linked transmitters with more This means that many populations of mobulids must find high precise position estimates may facilitate the inclusion of these biomass food patches in a dilute food environment.

Stomach important physical and biological features into spatial analyses. For example, in Mexico Graham et al. Ontogenetic shifts in movements and habitat use are observed in co-occurring species Notarbartolo di Sciara, ; common in elasmobranchs Grubbs, Juvenile mobulids Rohner et al.

Similarly, studies evaluating the prey are rarely seen and presumably exhibit size or age segregation community alongside feeding mobulids showed that M. Consequently, critical habitat use and movements likely prey are available and when zooplankton meet specific density vary among life stages in mobulid rays. Future studies could seek thresholds Armstrong et al. Results from to address these ontogenetic differences, in particular by filling studies using stable isotopes and fatty acids as trophic tracers knowledge gaps in the movements and habitat use of juvenile and support direct observation data that mobulids are predominantly young-of-year mobulids.

Large Collaborative Efforts Couturier et al. Ongoing efforts to monitor mobulid movements through photo- Further, some studies have suggested that M. Jaine et al. Fortunately, strong collaborative studies should aim to identify common characteristics among momentum within the scientific community and developments their prey species such as community composition, biomass, size in analytical tools are now allowing for telemetry studies to spectra and swimming capacity.

Further, examination of diving take place at unprecedented scales, tracking movements of a capacities of mobulids will provide a better understanding of multitude of marine species across oceans and over several different foraging strategies across their range and how these are years e.

Acoustic affected by environmental variability e. Knowledge of prey landscapes alongside the movement and spatial use patterns of mobulids Croll drivers and types of movement is key to habitat modeling efforts et al. This site and species specificity in combination with limited sample sizes does not 7.

Incorporating Prey Data Into Mobulid sufficiently support our understanding of broad-scale patterns Studies at the population or species level. We recommend that future Understanding oceanographic mechanisms that influence the studies emphasize multi-species and multi-region tagging efforts distribution of mobulids will be important for identifying to define critical habitats, resolve patterns in movement and critical habitats that warrant special protection see section connectivity among populations, improve our understanding of 6.

Movements: Critical habitats. However, the temporal lag species-specific drivers of movement, and support efforts for between primary productivity, which can be observed via management and bycatch reduction.

The majority of direct observations of foraging are from epipelagic waters. However, a broad range of methods including isotope and fatty acid analysis, archival satellite tagging, stomach content analysis and submersible observations indicate that mesopelagic prey are important diet items for mobulids. References for this figure are listed in Table S2.

See section 7. Incorporating prey e. Improving Inference From Isotope and distribution and foraging studies will be essential for identifying Fatty Acid Analyses the environmental and food web patterns that drive mobulid Given the limitations of temporal coverage in stomach content movements and distributions.

When possible, researchers should analyses, a number of studies have employed stable isotope strive to collect prey data concurrently with mobulid sightings analysis and fatty acid profiling to examine the diet of mobulid and behavioral data McCauley et al. However, in studies using telemetry and et al. While diet-tissue fisheries data this may not be feasible. Instead, researchers could discrimination values and turnover rates have been examined for take advantage of existing oceanographic datasets with high- several elasmobranchs Hussey et al.

We encourage they have not been determined for any mobulid species to date, researchers to consider what prey data are available at or near meaning that inferences of diet and trophic position in mobulids their proposed study region, and even to consider specifically have been based entirely on estimated values.

Captive feeding targeting regions with large oceanographic datasets for future experiments on mobulids under controlled conditions in aquaria mobulid research. Additionally, we encourage researchers to are needed to evaluate turnover times, diet tissue discrimination collaborate with oceanographers and cruise planners to help factors, and validate the use of other tissue types that can be ensure that large-scale zooplankton data collection efforts are sampled by non-invasive means for biochemical analyses, such as most relevant to studies of higher trophic level organisms mucus Burgess et al.

Standardized protocols for sample including mobulids. Bridging the gap between oceanographic preservation e. Research Priorities for Mobulid Rays to improve general knowledge on mobulid feeding ecology. This technique provides a finer resolution on the origin reliance on these food sources and habitats will lead to improved of individual components e. In all isotopic studies, adequate 7. New Technology in Foraging Studies sampling of the food web and candidate diet items identified As technology develops, so too does the ability to track and in observational studies and stomach contents is necessary to monitor mobulids in remote and deep realms of the ocean.

In studies of the diving behavior of other interpretations on the dynamics of energy transfer in the pelagic marine species, accelerometers have been successfully used to environment.

The points indicate visits at either German Flag or Manta Alley on those days rounded to the nearest hour. The shaded bars indicate the time between 6 p. The GLM seasonal pattern appeared the reverse of that in the south, used 10, records, 1, indicating presence of tagged although animals were present in all months. The move- O manta rays. In six man- ticularly strong Table 4.

Figure 4 shows hits in relation to tas 25, 2B, 31, 30, 37 and 38 left southern Komodo in C both time of day and the tidal cycle, note that most hits are November and December and arrived at northern Komodo recorded during the day in south Komodo even at diVerent from 1 to 59 days later; two additional manta rays 1B and N tidal phases.

Figure 5 shows the compiled hits per hour at 34 left PK for north Komodo around the same time. These PK, south and north Komodo over a h period note, only mantas remained at the northern sites for up to 50 days U north and south Komodo were included in the GLM. The before leaving although one animal 38 was recorded number of hits gradually increased during the morning and infrequently through May.

This pattern was not observed in then decreased again prior to sunset with a peak shifted indicating the potential for inter-annual diVerences. MOON at north Komodo, manta ray abundance was higher The second strongest interaction was between AA and when currents are strongest during full and new moons.

In the south, the most visits occurred from April The GLM includes all visits over a h period; an exami- to July and then declined until December after which no nation of nighttime visits alone reveals a diVerent pattern. In the north, the Around the full moon in south Komodo the number of Large xxxx Dispatch: The tem- 0. No similar increase in nighttime visits was day, tides, lunar phase, and season.

Here we present the observed at the other sites. The eVect of TIDES was also most comprehensive analysis of manta ray movements pub- PR more pronounced in north with more visits during the rising lished to date. Acoustic arrays have proven a valuable tool in this and other studies Klimley and Halloway ; Sundstrom Visual surveys et al. There are however limitations. First, it is not pos- TE counted varied between 0 and 83, averaging 8. The cor- sible to determine where a tagged animal is when it is not rected number of visits from the acoustic receivers varied recorded or to distinguish between animals leaving the between 0 and 3.

The value of study area and tag shedding. Recep- Temperature tion range was particularly low in the south, nonetheless, R these receivers collected the most data. The high number of Temperatures varied with season, tidal cycles and across detections at GF in particular may result from its location R sites. The highest In addition, foraging mantas were O most notable seasonal pattern with maximum temperatures observed to repeat the same route, which would increase observed in the Wrst quarter and the lowest values in the the probability of detection.

While estimates of manta pres- C third quarter of the year. In the north the temperature range ence are undoubtedly conservative at all sites, the agree- N Fig. These model estimates ap- 0. Based on our observations, the mantas returned to 35 SK the sites in the park for both feeding and cleaning.

The temperature range the animals are just outside the range of the array or have Author Proof at each site is also indicated left the park. Similarly, manta rays in Bora Bora are not O recorded for months at a time before returning although ment between visual and acoustic surveys suggests that the with only Photo ID this pattern is diYcult to conWrm S. Mantas returned to the same site almost daily for up to to resolve movements of mantas when they are not detected 3 months and visited sporadically for up to 2 years.

Mantas by the receivers. While most mantas with longer records visited at least two areas, movements between areas were somewhat The examination of diurnal patterns shows the highest tag limited.

Thus, while there is clearly exchange between sites, activity at all sites during daylight hours. The time of there may be residency patterns within the park.

Through photo identiWcation manta rays One possible explanation for the diurnal pattern is that the have been documented to regularly return to speciWc feed- mantas are moving oVshore during the night possibly to ing or cleaning stations over long time periods. An individ- feed on the deep scattering layer DSL when it approaches R ual manta studied in the Yaeyama Islands, Japan for the surface Tont ; Robinson and Gomez-Gutierrez example, was observed in the area for 15 years Homma This could help to explain the slight shift to later R et al.

Manta rays observed oV the big island of hours at the northern site, which is farther from deeper Hawaii have been re-sighted over similarly long periods water.

There is evidence for oV-shore movement and feed- O T. Clark, personal communication. Manta rays that were studies started more recently, the same mantas have been actively tracked oV Japan moved oVshore at night and then C observed returning to the same cleaning stations for over returned the following day K.

Yano, personal communica- 2 years S. In many tion. While this may occur in other regions as well no pub- N locations it is also common for individuals to be lished accounts are available. Another member of the same documented only once S. Walker, personal communica- family Mobula japonica feeds on crustaceans primarily at U tion; K.

Yano, personal communication raising the ques- night when they come to the surface D. Croll et al. This could unpublished data. A number of other elasmobranchs explain some of the shorter records observed in this study including scalloped hammerheads, blacktip reef sharks and although it is impossible to determine whether mantas left gray reef sharks are also observed to aggregate in near the area or lost their tags.

Clearly more Klimley and Nelson ; Holland et al. Dolphin foraging was most often observed in association with tidal fronts in a narrow estua- While the acoustic tags do not indicate when animals are rine channel oV Scotland Mendes et al. The two feeding, insights into foraging were gained through visual Wlter feeding sharks also forage in tidal currents. Basking observations and by examining visitation patterns. Whale sharks position themselves the park. Mantas fed where prey appeared to be concen- to take advantage of tidal currents transporting material out trated both in the water column, where visibility was very of the lagoon on Ningaloo reef Australia Wilson et al.

The concentration of prey is Similar to these other species, mantas appear to take considered to be critical for Wlter feeders likely due to the advantage of the increase in prey density associated with energetic cost of feeding; foraging is observed in both bask- the strong tidal currents around Komodo Island.

Although it has not been lunar illumination. The increase in nighttime visits during Author Proof directly measured, prey density appears to be important for the full moon but not the new moon in south Komodo sug- O mantas as well. This shift could be densities in the Komodo Marine Park. Mantas were most abundant in the south EC shore likely bringing additional resources from oV-shore during the summer and in the north during the winter.

These processes will enhance the While maximum abundances were reversed between the biomass of available prey in the park beyond that produced two sites, this pattern did not result solely from a shift from locally.

More visits were documented at in north Komodo at the While it is diYcult to identify the driving force behind rising tide when currents move from the south to the north the seasonal change in manta abundance, it is likely linked O when the moon was new or full and tidal Xux is greatest. The shift in abundance Tidal currents in this area shift degrees with each tidal corresponds to the monsoonal shift in the Indo-PaciWc that C change and can be up to 5 knots.

In contrast, the inXuence inXuences both temperature and productivity. During the of tidal current and phase was less pronounced in south Wrst quarter when no mantas were observed in south Kom- N Komodo. In this region the variation in strength and direc- odo the Indian Equatorial Counter Current and north mon- tion of tidal currents is lower than in the north and therefore soon are the driving processes Tomczak and Godfrey U one might expect a less pronounced eVect of lunar and tidal At this time there is a reduction in the net Xow from phase on visitation patterns.

It was during this quarter that less dependent on tidal strength or speciWc direction. Over the same period in nomic groups and impacts the temporal and spatial patterns north Komodo, waters are cool with poor visibility. From in feeding. In a comparison of marine birds with diVerent May to September when visitation in south Komodo is prey preferences, the plankton feeder, Ancient Murrelets, high, the South Equatorial Current and southeast monsoon were most active when tidal Xow was the greatest Holm are both fully developed which maximizes westward Xow Large xxxx Dispatch: Mantas are also perature and large increase in productivity Hahude and taken in other locations throughout Indonesia although at Gordon During this phase, the waters in the south lower levels.

Additional information on the larger-scale are cool and murky visibility ca. As indicated above, mantas have the potential to be highly As mentioned above, seasonal shifts in manta distribu- susceptible to over Wshing and vigilance is warranted. The Weld research New Zealand mantas are observed primarily in the austral could not have been conducted without the assistance of The Nature summer DuVy and Abbott Ahjua, per- F Indonesia who spent long hours on the water.

We also thank Russ sonal communication. In the Maldives seasonal shifts are Vetter and Jason Larese for their valuable comments on the manu- script. The conclusions stated herein reXect the opinions of the authors O thought to be associated with the local monsoons, when Author Proof and not the National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration. In the Kom- Indonesia. Shark News The predictability of the spatial distribution of manta rays Arnold G, Dewar H Electronic tags in marine Wsheries research: has important consequences for conservation and tourism a year perspective.

The information on patterns of occurrence ging and tracking in marine Wsheries. Yale For management and conservation, the high site Wdelity and University, New Haven, pp — ability to predict spatial patterns has two implications.

First, Blaxter JHS The role of light in the vertical migration of Wsh— R there is the potential for localized depletion or extirpation a review. Blackwell, Oxford, pp — once Wshers start exploiting an aggregation site. J Acoust areas based around aggregations sites should have a direct Soc Am O positive eVect on local abundance. Compagno LJV Checklist of living elasmobranchs. John Hopkins University Press, Maryland, pp — C whether the boundaries of the park serve to protect the local Dewar H Preliminary report: manta ray harvest in Lamakera.

Clearly, the park encom- Report to the World Wildlife Fund. Bull Mar Sci — U during the day. One of the greatest satellites with temperature data from tags on Wsh. Fish Bull potential threats are the Wsheries in Lamalera and Lama- — kera, which are approximately km from the park.

Domeier ML, Nasby N Annual re-sightings of photographically Manta ray migrations as far as km have been docu- identiWed white sharks Carcharodon carcharias in an eastern PaciWc aggregation site Guadalupe Island, Mexico. Mar Biol. In Lamakera it is estimated that New Zealand, with conWrmation of the occurrence of Manta bi- approximately 1, mantas are taken in the Wshing season rostris.

Am Fish Soc Symp —10 Seas. There are two effects that water has on light that is important to understand. Firstly, since water is more dense than air, light does not travel as well in water. The result of this is that the deeper you go, the darker the environment you have to work with becomes. This will cause a significant loss in certain colours. The first one to diminish would be the red one, while the blue and the green will pop up.

Something you might have noticed when going scuba diving. It is the way you design how and where you put your subject marine life in the frame, as well as what to have in the background and foreground.

For example, if you are taking a photo of a fish you should choose a simple background so that your subject can be in the centre of attention, rather than having it in front of a crowded background with other objects with similar colours.

Choosing what camera to get can be a difficult task. Getting an expensive, high-end camera will no doubt give you a powerful solution. On the other hand, in order to be able to fully utilize its potential, you need to get familiar with all features and details. A more budget-friendly, point-and-shoot camera will do most of the job for you when it comes to settings and colour balance.



How to start with Underwater Photography – Manta Dive

Using a general linear model it was possible to examine the effects of daytime, lunar phase, aggregation site, season and tidal phase on visitation patterns. There are many situations decline in zooplankton biomass at the tropics could impacts where multiple research groups working in the same region local areas where mobulids feed, the most likely outcome may be able to pool resources to maintain key project areas for is that there will be lower zooplankton biomass available extended periods. To examine the movements of manta rays in the Komodo Marine Park, Indonesia, an acoustic array was installed at up to seven sites in the park between and The GLM seasonal pattern appeared the reverse of that in the south, used 10, records, 1, indicating presence of tagged although animals were present in all months. For example, in Mexico Graham et al. We collected data on catch numbers, body sizes, sex, and maturity status for five mobulid species. Scientific reports DNA analysis of traded shark fins and mobulid gill plates reveals a high proportion of species of conservation concern.